Legal Rules/Property

Landlord-Tenant Law (Types of Tenancies)

Quick Answer

What is the Landlord-Tenant Law (Types of Tenancies)?

The four types of landlord-tenant estates: tenancy for years (fixed term), periodic tenancy (auto-renewing), tenancy at will (terminable at any time), and tenancy at sufferance (holdover tenant).

Source: Garner v. Gerrish, 63 N.Y.2d 575 (1984)

Definition

Landlord-tenant law recognizes four types of leasehold estates, each with distinct characteristics regarding duration, termination, and the rights of the parties. A tenancy for years (also called a term of years) has a definite beginning and ending date and terminates automatically without notice at the end of the term. Despite its name, it can be for any fixed period -- a week, a month, or multiple years.

A periodic tenancy is a recurring estate that automatically renews at the end of each period (month-to-month, year-to-year, etc.) unless either party gives proper notice of termination. At common law, the notice period for a periodic tenancy equals the length of the period, up to a maximum of six months for a year-to-year tenancy. Many modern statutes modify these notice requirements. A periodic tenancy can be created expressly, by implication (such as when a tenant pays rent on a regular basis without a lease), or by operation of law (such as when a holdover tenant's rent is accepted).

A tenancy at will has no fixed duration and can be terminated by either party at any time, though most jurisdictions now require some reasonable notice. A tenancy at sufferance arises when a tenant wrongfully remains in possession after the lease has expired (a holdover tenant). The landlord has two options: treat the holdover as a trespasser and pursue eviction, or elect to bind the holdover to a new periodic tenancy (typically on the same terms as the expired lease). Once the landlord makes this election, it is generally binding on both parties.

Key Elements

  1. 1Tenancy for years: fixed term with definite start and end dates; no notice required to terminate
  2. 2Periodic tenancy: auto-renewing; requires proper notice to terminate (typically equal to the period, up to 6 months)
  3. 3Tenancy at will: no fixed term; terminable by either party at any time with reasonable notice
  4. 4Tenancy at sufferance: holdover tenant wrongfully in possession; landlord may evict or create a new periodic tenancy
  5. 5All tenancies require a landlord-tenant relationship (privity of estate and/or privity of contract)

Landmark Cases

Garner v. Gerrish

63 N.Y.2d 575 (1984)

Held that a lease granting the tenant the right to terminate at will, but not the landlord, created a valid life tenancy (or determinable life estate) rather than a tenancy at will, because the traditional rule that a tenancy at will must be terminable by both parties is no longer rigidly applied.

Crechale & Polles, Inc. v. Smith

295 So. 2d 275 (Miss. 1974)

Addressed the landlord's election when a tenant holds over, establishing that the landlord must make a clear and unequivocal choice between eviction and renewal.

Javins v. First National Realty Corp.

428 F.2d 1071 (D.C. Cir. 1970)

While primarily about the implied warranty of habitability, this case reshaped the understanding of the landlord-tenant relationship from a property-based to a contract-based framework.

Exam Tips

  • Classify the tenancy type before analyzing any other issue -- the type determines notice requirements, termination rules, and holdover consequences.
  • For periodic tenancies, know the common-law notice rule: notice must equal one full period, up to a maximum of six months for a year-to-year tenancy.
  • When a tenant holds over, ask whether the landlord has elected to treat the tenant as a trespasser or as a new periodic tenant. The landlord's acceptance of rent after expiration typically creates a new periodic tenancy.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Calling every lease a 'tenancy for years' -- a tenancy for years requires a fixed end date. A month-to-month arrangement is a periodic tenancy, not a tenancy for years.
  • Assuming a holdover tenant has a right to remain -- a tenancy at sufferance gives the tenant no rights; it merely describes the tenant's status while the landlord decides what to do.

Memory Aid

Four tenancies in order of certainty: Years (fixed), Periodic (auto-renew), Will (either party ends it), Sufferance (wrongful holdover). YPWS.

Related Rules

Students Also Study

Master Every Rule with Briefly

Get unlimited access to AI case briefs, flashcards, outlines, and 6,432+ pre-written briefs. 3-day free trial, then $9.99/month.