Legal Rules/Property

Covenant Running with the Land

Quick Answer

What is the Covenant Running with the Land?

A promise concerning the use of land that binds not only the original parties but also subsequent owners of the burdened property, enforceable at law through damages.

Source: Spencer's Case, 5 Co. Rep. 16a, 77 Eng. Rep. 72 (1583)

Definition

A real covenant (or covenant running with the land) is a promise respecting the use of land that is enforceable at law by and against subsequent owners of the land, not just the original contracting parties. When a covenant 'runs with the land,' it means that the benefits and burdens of the covenant pass automatically to successors in interest, so that a subsequent purchaser of the burdened property must comply with the covenant and a subsequent purchaser of the benefited property can enforce it.

For a covenant to run with the land at law, several requirements must be met. First, the original parties must have intended the covenant to bind successors (often indicated by language such as 'this covenant shall run with the land' or 'binding on heirs and assigns'). Second, the covenant must 'touch and concern' the land, meaning it must relate to the use, enjoyment, or value of the land rather than being a purely personal obligation. Third, there must be horizontal privity between the original covenanting parties (they must share some independent legal relationship regarding the land, such as grantor-grantee). Fourth, there must be vertical privity between the original party and the successor (the successor must hold the same estate as the original party).

Real covenants are distinguished from equitable servitudes, which are enforceable in equity through injunctive relief and have somewhat relaxed requirements (notably, horizontal privity is not required for equitable servitudes). The modern trend, reflected in the Restatement (Third) of Property: Servitudes, is to merge the concepts of real covenants and equitable servitudes into a unified category of 'covenants' and to simplify the privity requirements.

Key Elements

  1. 1A written promise concerning the use of land (Statute of Frauds applies)
  2. 2Intent that the covenant run with the land and bind successors
  3. 3The covenant must touch and concern the land
  4. 4Horizontal privity between the original covenanting parties (for burden to run at law)
  5. 5Vertical privity between the original party and the successor
  6. 6Notice to the successor (actual, constructive, or inquiry notice)

Landmark Cases

Spencer's Case

5 Co. Rep. 16a, 77 Eng. Rep. 72 (1583)

The foundational case establishing the requirements for a covenant to run with the land at law, including the touch and concern requirement.

Neponsit Property Owners' Association v. Emigrant Industrial Savings Bank

278 N.Y. 248 (1938)

Broadly interpreted the touch and concern requirement to include monetary obligations (annual charges for maintenance) that indirectly benefit the land.

Tulk v. Moxhay

2 Ph. 774, 41 Eng. Rep. 1143 (1848)

While primarily establishing equitable servitudes, this case also clarified the distinction between enforcement at law (real covenants) and enforcement in equity.

Exam Tips

  • Analyze the burden and benefit sides separately -- the requirements for the burden to run are stricter than for the benefit to run.
  • Horizontal privity is the most commonly tested element. Remember that it requires an independent legal relationship (e.g., grantor-grantee, landlord-tenant) between the original parties.
  • If the covenant cannot run at law because a privity requirement is not met, consider whether it can be enforced as an equitable servitude in equity.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Confusing horizontal privity (relationship between original parties) with vertical privity (relationship between an original party and a successor) -- they are different requirements.
  • Failing to analyze the benefit and burden sides separately; the covenant may run on one side but not the other.

Memory Aid

Real covenants require INTHV: Intent, Notice, Touch and concern, Horizontal privity, Vertical privity.

Related Rules

Students Also Study

Master Every Rule with Briefly

Get unlimited access to AI case briefs, flashcards, outlines, and 6,432+ pre-written briefs. 3-day free trial, then $9.99/month.